• Home
  • About
  • Become a contributor
  • Contact

DisputedPast

A history blog with the latest from the past
  • News
    • Archaeology
    • Art
    • Biography
    • Espionage
    • Government
    • Religion
    • Sexuality
    • Society
    • Technology
    • War
  • Scrutinized
  • Documentaries
  • Reviews

Why corporal punishment on schools was invented

15 December 2013 by Jan Huisman in Middle Ages News Society - No Comments

Until recently, it was common practice on schools to conduct corporal punishment on unruly students. Medievalist Dr. Ben Parsons researched the origins of this violent teaching method. He found out that medieval philosophers thought there were many benefits to these methods. For instance, it was believed that pain helped students to remember their wrongdoing. A beating helped students to remind who was the boss, and the fear of a getting another beating moulded them into obedient students.

Alexander of Neckam (1157-1227) nevertheless states that the rod should be withdrawn when things are done as required. In addition, the punishment should be proportional to the offense committed by the student. When their ‘crime was ugly’, the punishment should subsequently be bitter. Vincent of Beauvais (1190-1264) argued that a formal warning should precede the beating and that the punishment should be adjusted to the character of the offender. Moreover, the corporal punishment should happen on a public place with an audience.

Dr. Ben Parsons states that the beating of schoolchildren has been an accepted schooling method for centuries. It is now clear how and why corporal punishment was invented in the Middle Ages, but why have we continued to beat children on school as a part of their education stays unclear. Somehow, it was general accepted that instruction was accompanied by violence. This longstanding link between schooling and flogging is attested by a range of artifacts, like whipping tools and rods. An overview of corporal punishments is recorded in The Harrow Punishment Book, a book for schoolmasters from the Edwardian era. Teachers could read here exactly what type of beating they should give their students for their crimes.

 

  • pinterest
  • facebook
  • twitter
  • google
  • linkedin
  • stumbleupon

Jan Huisman

Previous Story
Polish hero Witold Pilecki went to Auschwitz in 1940 - voluntarily
Next Story
Why Japan had to abolish state-Shinto 68 years ago

Related Posts

  • Noah’s Ark was in fact a round vessel: a giant coracle
  • The Nazi-past of Dr. Oetker
  • Neanderthals nurtured and had good parenting skills
  • Roman gladiators were vegetarians
    History’s most unexpected veggies? The bloodthirsty Roman gladiators
  • Persephone abducted
    Mosaic of Persephone discovered in ancient tomb
  • Today is Willy Brandt’s 100th birthday
  • Case closed on Katyn massacre

Leave a Comment

Cancel reply

Support this website by liking it on Social Media!

History news by Time Period

  • » Pre history
  • » Antiquities
  • » Middle ages
  • » Early modern age
  • » Modern age

Most read today

Newly added documentaries

  • Kings and Queens of England

    Get yourself comfortable and watch this 4,5 hour…

  • British Pathé shows a wide range of historical footage

    If you like old news footage you definitely have…

  • The real white queen and her rivals

    The Wars of the Roses raged through England from…

  • Henry VII: the Winter King

    Henry VII was the first Tudor-monarch of England.…

  • Henry VIII: The mind of a Tyrant

    Henry VIII is more than a historical figure: he…

  • Women and religion

    Another great documentary by Bettany Hughes.This…

  • Fire and Ice: The winter war

    The Winter War between Finland and Russia had a…

  • The Spanish Civil War

    The Spanish Civil War is regarded as the prelude…

Featured

  • What did the real Jesus look like?

    Our image of Jesus is that of a bearded, masculine figure. A man in agony, hanging on the cross, crucified for the sins of humanity. This rather gloomy presence is quite different in comparison to the Jesus from early Christianity. This original image of Christ is much debated lately, mainly… Read full history →

Scrutinized

  • The hunt for Germany’s nazi-criminals continues: 6000 suspects await investigation

    The leading executive of Germany’s center for nazi-crimes expects that about a dozen former concentration camp thugs are to be arrested. Chief attorney Kurt Schrimm told the Deutsche Presse Agentur (dap) the authorities are working on a list with all the guards at Auschwitz, 6,000 in number. Schrimm heads the center for nazi-crimes and he and 19 employees are on… Read full history →

Featured documentaries

  • The top 5 best history documentary series

    There are so many good history documentaries out there – and lots of crappy ones as well. As a historian and documentary lover, I watched a lot historical documentaries. Good ones. And many bad ones. This list is about the first group.True history documentaries, made by historians. Other criteria are… Read full history →

www.DisputedPast.com - A history blog with the latest from the past * Terms of service *